On Sutton Place | The Back

In this post: A simple, affordable and DIY update for a wood deck that includes stain, a railing fix and new accessories. 

In the spirit of keeping it real, I’m here today to share our back deck and how I fixed a mistake I made a few years ago. First of all, let me say that sometimes you just have to take a leap of faith and try something new. If, by chance, it doesn’t work out so well, you also must admit you were wrong. Which is what I’m doing today…but let me start at the beginning. Here (below) is our deck in late May. Notice the light gray stain.

On Sutton Place | The Back | Simple update for a wood deck that includes stain, a railing fix and new accessories. DIY and affordable.

Anyone who has a wood deck knows that the staining ritual needs to take place every few years. For us, it’s always a major ordeal. The last time we tackled it, I decided I wanted a giant bang for my buck, so I chose a completely different, much lighter stain color. Oh, did I love it. My happiness soon wore off because although very pretty, the gray quickly got dirty and was hard to clean.

On Sutton Place | The Back | Simple update for a wood deck that includes stain, a railing fix and new accessories. DIY and affordable.

My husband has spent the past three years saying I told you so…because he warned me, but I didn’t listen. So after living with it a few years and trying my best to keep it clean, I admitted defeat, and went back to a brown stain for the deck floor.

On Sutton Place | The Back | Simple update for a wood deck that includes stain, a railing fix and new accessories. DIY and affordable.

It does show dirt, but not nearly like the gray did…and most of the time I can tidy up with just a blower. After searching on Pinterest for deck colors, I decided to go with a white railing. This pin was my inspiration. I am, so far, very happy with my choice. Not only does it have an updated look, but the white railing lightens it up too.

On Sutton Place | The Back | Simple update for a wood deck that includes stain, a railing fix and new accessories. DIY and affordable.

I also had a problem with rotted posts. At first I thought I would have to replace every post in the railing…or remove the railing altogether. After thinking about it a while, I realized I could just cut off the post tops and add a finial.

On Sutton Place | The Back | Simple update for a wood deck that includes stain, a railing fix and new accessories. DIY and affordable.

I really wanted the post caps like in my inspiration picture, but I opted for the finials, because they were so much cheaper. The caps were over $10 each and the finials were just over $2.00. I needed eleven, so after I did the math, the finials won out. I think they give it a little classic charm and honestly, anything is better than the rotting posts I had before. 

On Sutton Place | The Back | Simple update for a wood deck that includes stain, a railing fix and new accessories. DIY and affordable.

So…at least for a few years my deck is squared away. On my never-ending wish list is a new deck made from composite decking. It’s not at the top of the list though, so chances are it will never become a reality. I’ve said many times, that of all the things about our home that I love, my favorite is the backyard area. Keeping that in mind, I just might move that new deck up a rung or two on the wish list!

Helpful links:

Deck Stain: Sherwin Williams SuperDeck in Pine Cone
Umbrella: Ballard
Chaise cushion: Ballard
Black Planters: Amazon (aff. link)
Chair pillow covers: IKEA

Back Deck Before and After
Vintage Galvanized Wash Tub Herb Garden

ann signature with bird

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

59 Comments

  1. Your deck is beautiful. I just moved from a home that had a composite deck. Although it was nearly maintenance free, it wasn’t completely so. Perhaps there are different types, but our posts and railings were plastic. There were several chipped places and it was easily stained by bird droppings. I didn’t think they were as pretty as wood. The decking itself had boards that had faded and were rougher than the others. I suppose there is no such thing as totally maintenance free, and there are always trade-offs when choosing materials.

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Thank you Rebecca! I honestly don’t think I would install composite decking now after reading all the comments on this post. I agree that bird droppings are very hard to get out and I also agree that there is no such thing as maintenance-free!

  2. roxanne vitai says:

    Hi Ann! I don’t have a deck yet, it’s on my wish list, but your post reminded me of a visit to a friends a few weeks ago. She and her husband have expanded their deck and in doing so had to re-stain to try to make it all match. Anyway, the interesting thing to me was that they painted the railings black and stained the other parts a reddish brown. The effect was stunning, I thought the black parts were wrought iron until I touched them. My friend says that neighbors have stopped by and asked if they re-did their deck with iron. Its given the deck a Tuscany look, I think. I love your blog, your home is lovely!

  3. Your deck looks great! My deck floor is the same color as your current color. My thought for next season was to stain it gray so I read your post with great interest. Maybe I will just do the railings white and take it from there! I don’t have anyone to tell me I told so, so maybe your advice will prevent me from making a mistake!!!

  4. Kim @ Vintage Pretties says:

    I love how the railings turned out and I like the finials far better than the caps. The finials look custom!

  5. Hi Ann,
    Mistake ?, oh I don’t know. We learn what we like through these types of trials. We are siding our house this year. We have had a grey deck for years. We actually picked the color as it resembles weathered wood . We hoped it wouldn’t show that really our decks need to be done every year!!… reading this makes me realize it may actually be easier to have a darker color. Next spring I think we shall be staining a darker color. I like your light rails. Yours spaces seem to have a tidy quality I find very appealing. Thanks for letting us follow along. Now I too know that a light deck is harder to keep up than a dark one. I just thought they were all that way! : / Kathy

    1. Ann Drake says:

      If the grey deck had looked weathered I probably would have loved it. Mine just looked dirty…all the time! Good luck with your stain decision. :)

  6. I’m so glad I found your beautiful blog. Everything is so clean looking and polished. It inspires me to get busy on my little home. Thank you

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Welcome to On Sutton Place Tammy!

  7. Joanne B. says:

    Here’s another thumbs down on the composite decking material. We built a summer house abut 10 years ago and my husband wanted to try out the composite material so we used it for a small
    6X10 deck area and 3 steps that leads to our screened in front porch. In the back we used pressure treated wood for our deck that is approximately 15X 20. My husband is quite disappointed in the way the composite out front has ‘weathered’ and is deciding if he should replace it with wood or try painting it. The wood deck in back did require re-staining every few years, but he almost didn’t mind doing that, because he sort of expected it. If anything, maybe use the ‘fake wood’ railing stuff to avoid having to point al those spindles! He hoped the composite would be ‘maintenance free’ which it has proven not to be. Since wood cost less to begin with, for us, maintenance requirements being somewhat equal, wood was a better budget choice for us.

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Thank you Joanne! Using the composite railing sounds like a great idea. I will definitely do some research if we ever decide to replace.

  8. You might think twice about the composite deck. We replaced our wooden deck with one a few years ago and have regretted it. I’m sure that brands perform differently but ours actually requires more maintance despite the sales pitch. Within a week the color was almost completely faded out, we don’t eat out there because if any thing spills on it it stains, if there are any leaves on it when it rains they stain it, mildew stains, boards warp, etc. I haven’t found any thing that completely cleans it. Looking forward to replacing it with wood if and when i can ever afford it. So much for the low maintance! Be sure to research the different brands before making this investment. I took the contractors suggestion and made a $7000.00 mistake.

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Oh my gosh Debi thank you so much for your honesty. I will definitely think twice if we ever replace. At this point maybe I’ll stick with what I have!

  9. U need to look at back deck post

  10. Hi Ann,
    I did the same thing as you last year and stained my deck color to gray. I love the color but it is doing all the things you talked about in your post and I am so frustrated with it!! I told my husband we will have to go back to a darker color very soon. So disappointed with the gray after all the hard work to get it to that color which I do love!! The never ending projects with owning a home…ha!!
    Lynn

    1. Ann Drake says:

      I feel your pain! I adored the gray but just could not live with it any longer. Thanks for taking the time to leave a comment. :)

  11. I thought the gray floor was pretty in the picture but from what you said, the wood stain sounded more practical and it is pretty too, so win-win. The fence looks great. Backyards are dear to our heart so back deck may stay relatively high on the list.

  12. We also just stained our deck a dark brown. We had the whole decking replaced about 3 years ago and went with white trex railings. I also love the contrast and it looks good against our blue house.
    Yours looks more pulled together than mine though, with all the rain we’ve had I can’t have pillows!
    Love your blog!

  13. Linda Sangirardi says:

    Hi Ann,

    Love the changes you made to your deck! They are subtle but really pop, especially the finials… nice job!

    Linda

  14. Shannon Janson says:

    I think the brown on the deck makes it stand out! The light color just blended into the house color. The new finial are great!

  15. Jane @ Cottage at the Crossroads says:

    Love your finial solution, Ann! We stained our deck about 3 years ago, and although it has held up very well, it needs a little touching up. The dark brown color looks very handsome on your deck!

  16. Ann it looks great!! It sounds and looks to me as if you made a very good choice. Love the galvanized containers full of lush plants. You always do a beautiful job on your home and yard, Happy Sunday,
    Kathysue

  17. Penny @ The Comforts of Home says:

    I think your deck looks wonderful! I love your galvanized tubs!

  18. Carol Athenour says:

    I love your new brown. It grounds your deck. We have a wrap around porch…the way we chose our stain color was to match the dirt color. We have had it for years…looks good & I sweep every now & then.

  19. Marlene Stephenson says:

    Your deck is a nice size and really looks like a great place to spend some time.Thanks for the info guess that took care of my decision i was trying to make about my deck floor.

  20. Melba Hanska says:

    If it is any consolation to you, I very much prefer the looks of the finials over the caps. It gives the railing a much more gracious appearance. The stain is beautiful, as well, and probably does not reflect the heat into the house. You have inspired me to spend some elbow grease on the back patio. I don’t have a deck, but a nice railing around the patio with finials would really add to the appearance. Thanks for the inspiration.
    Melba Hanska

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Thank you Melba! I am actually starting to love the finials myself. :)

  21. I think your deck is lovely, Ann—you had issues and you found solutions. Good for you!

    Jane x

  22. Donna Marie says:

    I can’t believe how much better the brown looks than the grey!!! Your decorating always looks great!!! Love your blog!!!

  23. I do like the light grey, but I think your deck stands out more with the brown. I love your deck and backyard!!! It all looks so cozy:)

  24. Ricki Jill Treleaven says:

    WOW! You have a great outdoor living space, plus a large screened porch. You are one lucky duck!

    I can see why you liked the lighter color decking, but you really didn’t have anything that “grounded” your space. As an artist, I can assure you that the darker decking “grounds” your space. If I were painting your backyard, I would have painted your decking darker for contrast even if it were light like in the before photos. Plus you’ve added the galvanized planters that reflect light and add sparkle, so I’d say that you made good choices all the way around. (JMHO)

    xo,
    RJ

  25. Chris Johnson says:

    Today’s post is so timely. My husband just handed me a brochure of deck stains and I was leaning toward a gray. What color did you finally select? I enjoy your varied range of topics. Thank you.

    1. Ann Drake says:

      The color is Pine Cone from Sherwin Williams. Good luck!

  26. I looks great Ann, I made the mistake of staining our deck and now it’s peeling. I think the next time around I will just seal it with a clear coat. Im not as fond of the color but the upkeep is too much. I need to pressure wash ours off and start over again before we put up the “For Sale” sign. I hope you are enjoying yours now:)

  27. Ann,

    How ironic…we just replaced a very worn out deck and my home is light gray.
    I love the white railings but I am struggling with what color to stain the floor later this fall after the wood has cured a bit. Your pictures are inspiring.

    I too thought composite was the way to go. My contractor advised me against it because the back of my home is totally south exposure. It gets very hot. Also when wet slippery.

    I have friends that either LOVE IT or HATE IT. I just didn’t want to risk the expense and not like it.

    You have a much much larger deck than I do and my wood replacement boards and railings cost $2,000. Can’t imagine what maintenance free would have been. If you really want to go that route…watch the Nov/Dec clearance sales at your local home improvement store. My friend was able to build a huge deck and fence for her multiple gardens at half the cost.

    As for keeping it stained and maintained…think about donating to a local Scout Troop, high school band, National Honor Society (HS), etc and have a mature group of young people come over stain. We did this several years ago after a storm went through and we had to replace our fence. I provided sub sandwiches, chips, pop, water and treats and we donated $ to their program. It was alllll done in one day. Many of those groups need service hours too so the donation doesn’t have to be crazy. Many were able to bring their own brushes.

    Thanks for the great post!

    1. Silly me – I forgot to mention we hired someone to tear off and replace the deck boards and railing.

    2. Ann Drake says:

      You are welcome June and thank you for your great advice. After reading all the comments on this post I think composite decking would be a mistake. Sounds like wood is the way to go. :)

  28. Oh…it looks fantastic! I wish my deck looked half as good as yours. We are in discussions about whether to paint ours, using one of those super deck paints…or replace using composite. I fear painting would be just a temporary fix. Hopefully by next year we will be able to replace. Enjoy your deck…it looks brand new! ;)

  29. What state do you live in Ann? I noticed the lemon tree sitting on the deck and I wondered where you lived to get that to grow.

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Hi Marsha! I am in Ohio. The lemon tree belongs to my husband and believe it or not, it’s about 40 years old. My husband got it on spring break when he was in college. He is now 62. :) We keep it inside over the winter but put it outside in the summer. It’s hanging in there!

  30. Mary from Virginia says:

    It looks beautiful! I loved the gray too, but honestly seeing this gorgeous pine cone stain, you chose well! The new stain gives it such a rich look. I like the new finials too! Great choices.

    May I ask where you purchased your galvanized containers? Did you line them with anything before planting? They look great!

    1. Mary from Virginia says:

      oops, I searched your blog and found your post about planting the herbs! Great information, and so informative. Thanks for the easy search button!

      1. Ann Drake says:

        Yay! I’m glad the search found what you were looking for. I love to hear that the blog is user friendly!

  31. Good morning Ann. We had Lowes construct our deck with their composite wood seven years ago. Yes, I chose gray for the floor, but we have a large outdoor rug under our table and chairs. We have the exact rod iron outdoor chairs I see on your deck. So comfortable. Your deck is lovely with those galvanized planters. Unfortunately, our deck faces west, and there isn’t one idea to fix the problem of hot sun from 2 in the afternoon till 7 in the evening. No, we won’t plant trees; neighbors have them and we would need a miracle to look outside one day and notice those trees had moved to the left six feet to bring on the shade. We do enjoy having our breakfast and lunches outdoors, and an evening sip of wine after 7p.m.

  32. Kathleen G says:

    Hi Ann, sounds like a darker stain is the way to go and I like your finials. A comfortable place to relax while enjoying a beautiful view of your serene backyard. Kathleen in Az

  33. Looks so fresh and inviting. We had the same problem with the deck stain. I choose a lighter color and every bit of dirt shows. Time to choose a darker shade. Just need it to be a little cooler so I can do the sanding and staining.

    I love the Mayne planters. I have had mine for almost 5 years. Still look great. I paid over a $100.00 a piece then.

    This year I found them for around $50.00 both the tall and cube style, now reduced to under $40.00.. The tall ones are lovely in the front courtyard and the squares cubes are perfect outside the garden gates and in front of the garage.

    I always enjoy reading your blog and getting inspiration.

    Hope you have a lovely weekend.

    Susan

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Hi Susan! Where did you find the square planters for $40? My daughter would love a pair. :)

  34. We have a friend we visit with a composite deck. It looks great and is low maintenance but it’s so hot that I can’ t walk across it with slippers on. It radiates the heat so we can’ t sit out there for long.

  35. Hi Ann, Your deck is very nice and the feel of real wood is so much nicer than composite decking. Thanks for sharing!

  36. I love your deck! It looks so peaceful and inviting. One question – how did you attach the finials to the posts?

    Thanks for all of your posts. I enjoy reading them.

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Hi Beth!
      The finials actually have a big screw on the bottom. We just drilled a pilot hole in the cut off post and then screwed them in. It was very easy!

  37. Your deck looks great! We’re in process now trying to sand our deck (hoping it might last longer this way). Your deck is exactly what I’m wanting to do. Can you tell me the brand and color of the stain you used?

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Hi Kay! It’s Sherwin Williams in the color Pine Cone.

  38. OH I totally feel your pain!! We are trying to sell our home and we added a few deck platforms out from the original old deck. Our house is light gray like yours and we were looking at dark colors but our realtor suggested a gray similar to the home…gray is “in” right now. But. We. Have. A. Dog….. and you can see every pine needle and leaf. And red footprints everywhere…I think the dog somehow managed to put a dirty paw on every square inch. haha.

    I am NOT going to do the whole thing again since we are moving to our new home before selling –so instead I purchased another entire gallon of this expensive restore paint, same color, and once we (and our dog!) move out I will roll the top of the boards one more time. sigh…

    1. Ann Drake says:

      Yes I know gray is very “in” and I honestly love it…but I hated the dirt more. :) Good luck with your move. Sounds exciting!

  39. Your deck looks amazing, Ann! You picked a winner! The pine cone color is a perfect contrast to the railings and the house color. I think I might just pop on over and sit awhile!

  40. Looks great, you might just want to stick with the wood deck. I have the composite deck and although it looks great, low maintenance and will probably last long after we have left this home it is almost not useable in the middle of a sunny afternoon because it heats up and radiates heat even if you are under an umbrella you can feel it.

  41. Karen @ The Decorated Nest says:

    I think it looks lovely and I love the finials and white rail with the stain! Those galvanized buckets look awesome too!

  42. Maureen L. says:

    OMG! I did the same thing. Changed the deck from dark brown to grey to match the house. What a mistake. After just 2 years, it looks a mess. It has been power washed and still looks dirty and scratched. After seeing yours, we need to go back to brown, too. Love the white railings. Thanks for the incentive to tackle another project!